Ekadashi kab hai? Smarta vs Vaishnava — ek simple guide

Short jawab: Ekadashi ek tithi hai, din nahi. Tithi kabhi bhi shuru ho sakti hai, subah 7 baje ya raat 11 baje. Isliye sawaal ye hai ki vrat kis din rakhein. Do badi paramparayein iska jawab alag rule se deti hain: Smarta aur Vaishnava. Isi wajah se kabhi-kabhi calendar mein do din likhe hote hain. Koi galat nahi hai, bas rule alag hai.

Apne shehar ki agli Ekadashi abhi dekhni hai? Aaj ka Panchang kholo, wahan Smarta aur Vaishnava dono din milenge.

2026 ki baaki Ekadashi (Delhi)

EkadashiSmarta vratVaishnava vrat
Prabodhini / Devutthana (Kartik Shukla)
Ekadashi tithi: 20 Nov 07:16 se 21 Nov 06:31
Shukra, 20 Nov
Parana 21 Nov, 13:10–15:17*
Shani, 21 Nov
Parana 22 Nov, 06:49–08:56
Utpanna (Margashirsha Krishna)
Tithi: 3 Dec 23:03 se 4 Dec 23:45
Shukra, 4 Dec
Parana 5 Dec, 06:59–09:04
Shukra, 4 Dec
Parana 5 Dec, 06:59–09:04
Mokshada (Margashirsha Shukla)
Tithi: 19 Dec 22:09 se 20 Dec 20:14
Ravi, 20 Dec
Parana 21 Dec, 07:09–09:13
Ravi, 20 Dec
Parana 21 Dec, 07:09–09:13

Times IST, Delhi ke liye, hamare open-source engine (astronomy-engine) se calculate kiye gaye; ±1–2 min. Mahine ke naam purnimanta (North India) parampara se. *Is case mein parana ka samay granthon mein do mat wala hai (neeche dekho), isliye ise “review” maana gaya hai. Local parampara alag ho sakti hai — apne pandit/sampradaya se confirm karein.

Pehle 4 shabd samjho

  • Dashami-vedha: “vedha” yaani chhed. Agar Ekadashi wale din ke ek khaas samay par abhi Dashami chal rahi ho, to wo Ekadashi “viddha” (Dashami se chhui hui) maani jaati hai, aur us din vrat nahi hota.
  • Arunodaya: suryoday se 4 ghatika pehle ka samay. 1 ghatika = 24 minute, to 4 ghatika = 96 minute.
  • Parana: vrat kholna. Ye agle din, Dwadashi tithi ke andar karna hota hai.
  • Hari-vasara: Dwadashi ka pehla chauthai (1/4) hissa. Is samay parana nahi kiya jaata.

GRANTH PRAMAAN Rule, kitaab aur page ke saath

Hum do granth use karte hain: Dharma Sindhu (Kashinatha Upadhyaya, 1790; Nirnaya Sagar Press edition, 1888) aur Nirnaya Sindhu (Kamalakara Bhatta, 17vi sadi; Gyan Sagar Press edition, Mumbai 1892). Page numbers inhi editions ke hain.

1. Do tarah ka vedha: suryoday vs arunodaya

Dharma Sindhu (p.11) saaf likhta hai ki vedha do tarah ka hai: arunodaya par Dashami ho to wo Vaishnava ke liye vedha hai, aur suryoday par Dashami ho to wo Smarta ke liye vedha hai.

“वेधोऽपि द्विविधः अरुणोदये दशमीवेधः सूर्योदये तद्वेधश्च । सूर्योदयात्प्राक् चतुर्घटिकात्मकोऽरुणोदयः”

— Dharma Sindhu, p.11 (page scan se padha gaya)

Yahi baat Nirnaya Sindhu (p.31) Madhava ko quote karke kehta hai: “अरुणोदयवेधोऽत्र वेधः सूर्योदये तथा । उक्तौ द्वौ दशमीवेधौ वैष्णवस्मार्तयोः क्रमात्”. Arunodaya ki lambai 4 ghatika hai, ye Nirnaya Sindhu p.29–31 mein charcha ke baad tay kiya gaya hai. Wahan doosre mat bhi likhe hain (jaise Hemadri ka “raat ka 1/8 hissa”), jinhe granth khud nahi maanta.

Simple bhasha mein: Smarta dekhte hain ki suryoday par kaunsi tithi hai. Vaishnava aur pehle, suryoday se 96 minute pehle, dekhte hain. Isliye agar Dashami suryoday se thoda pehle khatam hui, to Smarta ke liye din “shuddh” hai, par Vaishnava ke liye nahi.

Kaun Smarta, kaun Vaishnava? Dharma Sindhu (p.11) kehta hai ki bade-buzurg isse apni parivaar ki parampara se tay maante hain. Yaani ye aapke ghar ki parampara ka sawaal hai, kisi app ka nahi.

2. Smarta rule (suryoday-vedha)

Dharma Sindhu (p.11–12) 7–8 alag cases example ke saath deta hai, aur kehta hai ki aajkal har jagah shishta log Madhava ka mat maante hain (p.12: “सर्वत्र देशेषु प्रायो माधवोक्तानुसार एव प्रचार”). Ek zaroori baat jo kam log jaante hain:

  • Smarta Dashami-viddha Ekadashi ko tabhi chhodte hain jab agle din Dwadashi (ya dono tithiyan) suryoday ke baad bhi bachi hon (p.12: “उभयाधिक्ये द्वादशीमात्राधिक्ये च स्मार्तानां विद्धायास्त्यागो नान्यत्र”).
  • Agar Ekadashi itni chhoti ho ki kisi suryoday ko chhue hi nahi (“kshaya”), aur agle din parana ke liye Dwadashi na bache, to Smarta usi din vrat rakhte hain jis din Ekadashi chal rahi hai, chahe subah Dashami thi. Nirnaya Sindhu (p.33) Rishyashringa ko quote karta hai: agar parana ke din Dwadashi ek kala bhi na mile, to Dashami-viddha Ekadashi ka bhi vrat karo.

3. Vaishnava rule (arunodaya-vedha)

Dharma Sindhu (p.11) ke hisaab se: arunodaya par Dashami ho to wo Ekadashi chhod do aur Dwadashi ko vrat rakho (“अरुणोदयवेधवती विद्धा तां त्यक्त्वा वैष्णवैर्द्वादश्येवोपोष्या”). Aur agar Ekadashi shuddh bhi ho, par Ekadashi ya Dwadashi agle suryoday ke baad bhi chal rahi ho, to Vaishnava baad wala din lete hain (Dharma Sindhu p.17).

4. Parana aur Hari-vasara

  • Parana Dwadashi ke andar hona chahiye (Dharma Sindhu p.19: “द्वादशीमध्य एव कार्यम्”).
  • Dwadashi lambi ho to uska pehla chauthai hissa, Hari-vasara, chhod kar parana karo (Dharma Sindhu p.19; Nirnaya Sindhu p.38: “द्वादश्याः प्रथमः पादो हरिवासरसंज्ञितः”).
  • Normal case mein parana subah (din ke pehle 3 muhurta) mein. Agar Dwadashi bilkul na bache, to Trayodashi mein suryoday ke baad (Dharma Sindhu p.19).
  • Jab Hari-vasara subah ke samay ke baad tak chale, to granth mein do mat hain: zyada log subah kehte hain, “kuch” log aparahna (dopahar baad). Isi liye upar table mein 21 Nov ka Smarta parana “review” likha hai.

Example: 20–21 Nov 2026, Delhi

20 Nov ko suryoday 06:47 par tha aur Dashami 07:16 tak thi. Ekadashi 21 Nov 06:31 par khatam ho gayi, yaani 21 Nov ke suryoday (06:48) se pehle. Matlab Ekadashi ne kisi bhi suryoday ko nahi chhua (kshaya), aur agle din Dwadashi ki “vriddhi” bhi nahi thi.

  • Smarta: 20 Nov. Dharma Sindhu p.12 ka case: “अनुभयाधिक्यवती विद्धा … स्मार्तानामेकादश्यामुपवासः”.
  • Vaishnava: 21 Nov (Dwadashi ke din): wahi line aage kehti hai “वैष्णवानां द्वादश्यामुपवासः”.

Imaandaar note: Dharma Sindhu ke quotes page scan se check kiye gaye hain. Nirnaya Sindhu ke quotes abhi OCR (computer se padhe gaye text) par based hain aur unka proofreading chal raha hai; kuch aksharon mein chhoti galti ho sakti hai. Har rule ek scholar review ke liye bhi khula hai.

KATHA Kahaani

Ekadashi ki kai kahaaniyan sunai jaati hain. Hum yahan sirf wahi kahaani denge jiska exact shlok aur granth hum dikha sakein, aur uska kavya (poetic) matlab bhi kholenge. Social media par chalne wale kuch “facts” (jaise kisi kahaani ko Ekadashi se jodna) ka source humein abhi nahi mila, isliye hum unhe nahi dohra rahe.

Katha section jald.

SCIENCE Research kya kehti hai

  • Weight loss: Cochrane ka review (February 2026) jisme 22 randomized trials aur 1,995 adults the, usme intermittent fasting se weight loss mein standard diet advice ke mukable koi “clinically meaningful” extra fayda nahi mila. (Cochrane Library, CD015610.pub2; Cochrane news)
  • Raat ko der se khaana: Johns Hopkins ki ek chhoti study (20 healthy log) mein wahi dinner raat 10 baje khane par, shaam 6 baje ke mukable, blood sugar ka peak lagbhag 18% zyada aaya aur raat mein fat burning lagbhag 10% kam hui (Gu et al., J Clin Endocrinol Metab, 2020). Par 2025 ki ek doosri study (31 mahilayein) mein early vs late eating window se insulin sensitivity mein farq nahi mila (Peters et al., Sci Transl Med, 2025). Matlab: signal hai, pakka proof nahi.
  • Ekadashi ka khaas din, chand ka shareer par asar, ya anaaj na khane ka koi khaas fayda: abhi proof nahi. Humein aisi koi achhi quality ki study nahi mili. Iska matlab ye nahi ki parampara galat hai; matlab sirf itna hai ki science abhi is par kuch pakka nahi keh sakti.

Diabetes, pregnancy, ya regular dawai lene wale fast se pehle doctor se poochhein. Bachche, buzurg aur kamzor log nirjala vrat na rakhein jab tak doctor haan na kahe.

Short mein

  1. Ekadashi tithi hai; vrat ka din rule se tay hota hai.
  2. Smarta suryoday par dekhte hain, Vaishnava arunodaya (96 min pehle) par.
  3. Parana agle din Dwadashi mein, Hari-vasara ke baad.
  4. Apni parivaar ki parampara follow karo, aur shaq ho to pandit se poochho.

Apne shehar ka Panchang dekho → · Pramaan Panchang school