Abhimanyu ne chakravyuh garbh mein seekha? Drona Parva ka jawab

"Abhimanyu ne maa ke garbh mein chakravyuh sunna seekha" — yeh kahani kitni purani hai? Drona Parva 35.19 mein Abhimanyu khud kya kehta hai, mool shloka ke saath, granth mein kya likha hai, aur…

Itihaas Ka ArthPramaan · 5 source6 minUpdated 21 Nov 2026
Abhimanyu ne chakravyuh garbh mein seekha? Drona Parva ka jawab: Bohot Simple Hai cover image

💭 Hamari soch, aapki marzi. Yahan jo arth/vyakhya hai, wo hamara maanna hai, granth ka daawa nahi. Mool shloka aur granth mein jo likha hai, wo hum bina badle upar dikhate hain. Aap sehmat ho sakte hain, asehmat bhi. Dono theek hain. Hamara irada kisi ki aastha ko chot pahunchana bilkul nahi hai; phir bhi kisi ko bura lage to hum pehle se maafi maangte hain. Hum bhi seekh rahe hain. Nayi jaankari mili to post update karenge.

Itihaas Ka ArthMahabharat · Drona Parva · Abhimanyu-vadha

“Chakravyuh mein phans gaye.” Yeh muhavra aaj office politics, loan ke jaal aur exam ke pressure, sab ke liye bola jaata hai. Aur saath mein ek kahani aati hai: Abhimanyu ne maa Subhadra ke garbh mein Arjuna se chakravyuh mein ghusna seekha, lekin bahar nikalna sunne se pehle maa so gayi. Bachpan mein yeh kahani shayad aapne bhi dadi-nani se suni hogi.

Kya Mahabharat mein sach mein yeh likha hai? Pehle granth, phir alag se arth.

⚡ Seedha jawab

Mahabharat ke Drona Parva (Abhimanyu-vadha prasang) mein Abhimanyu khud kehta hai ki chakravyuh todne ka upaay use pita Arjuna ne sikhaaya hai, aur aapatti mein woh bahar nahi nikal paayega. K.M. Ganguli ke anuvaad ke is hisse mein garbh ka koi zikr nahi hai. Wikipedia garbh wali kahani ko “later folklore” batata hai.

Mahabharat mein Abhimanyu chakravyuh ke baare mein kya kehta hai?

उपदिष्टो हि मे पित्रा योगोऽनीकविशातने ।
नोत्सहे हि विनिर्गन्तुमहं कस्यांचिदापदि ॥

upadiṣṭo hi me pitrā yogo ‘nīkaviśātane |
notsahe hi vinirgantum ahaṃ kasyāṃcid āpadi ||

Source: Mahabharata, Drona Parva, adhyaya 35, shloka 19 (vedapath.app ki numbering). K.M. Ganguli ke English anuvaad mein yahi baat Drona Parva, Section XXXIII mein hai. Alag editions mein adhyaya number badal sakta hai.

Shabdik arth (hamara apna anuvaad): “Pita ne mujhe sena ke vyuh ko todne ka upaay sikhaaya hai. Lekin kisi aapatti mein main (usse) bahar nahi nikal paaunga.”

Ganguli ka anuvaad: “I have been taught by my father the method of (penetrating and) smiting this kind of array. I shall not be able, however, to come out if any kind of danger overtakes me.”

Terahvein din chakravyuh mein kya hua?

Yudh ke terahvein din Drona ek vyuh banate hain jise Ganguli ke anuvaad mein “chakra” array kaha gaya hai. Arjuna us samay doosri taraf yudh mein vyast hai. Ab Drona Parva ke is hisse mein (Section XXXIII–XXXIV, Ganguli) yeh hota hai:

  1. Yudhishthira ki chinta. Yudhishthira Abhimanyu se kehte hain ki is vyuh ko sirf chaar log tod sakte hain: “Thyself, or Arjuna or Krishna, or Pradyumna, can pierce that array.”
  2. Abhimanyu ka jawab. Upar wala shloka. Woh kehta hai ki pita ne sikhaaya hai, aur khud maanta hai ki aapatti mein bahar nahi aa paayega.
  3. Vaada. Yudhishthira kehte hain: “All of us will follow thee in the track by which thou wilt go.” Bhima bhi kehte hain ki woh khud, Dhrishtadyumna, Satyaki aur Panchal yoddha peechhe aayenge.
  4. Pravesh. Section XXXIV mein Abhimanyu vyuh tod kar andar ghus jaata hai. Ganguli uski “great lightness of hands” ki baat karte hain.
  5. Ant. Aage ke adhyayon mein Pandav peechhe nahi pahunch paate. Andar kai Kaurav maharathi ek saath Abhimanyu se ladte hain, aur usi upa-parva (Abhimanyu-vadha) mein uski mrityu hoti hai.

Granth mein kya hai, log kya poochhte hain

Sawaal: “Kya Abhimanyu ne garbh mein chakravyuh seekha tha?”

Granth (is prasang mein): Abhimanyu khud kehta hai “pita ne sikhaaya”. Ganguli ke anuvaad ke is section mein garbh ka koi zikr nahi hai.

Garbh wali kahani: Wikipedia ka Abhimanyu article ise “later folklore” (baad ki lok-katha) batata hai. Yeh kahani kis granth ya kis sadi se shuru hui, iski pakki tika humein abhi nahi mili. Mili to update karenge.

Aaj ke “chakravyuh” ke liye isse kya seekh milti hai? (Hamari soch)

Yeh hissa hamari vyakhya hai, granth ka daawa nahi.

Hamein is prasang mein teen baatein dikhti hain jo aaj bhi kaam ki hain.

1. Andar jaana aasaan, bahar aana mushkil. Abhimanyu ko pata tha ki use bahar nikalna nahi aata, aur usne yeh khud bola. Aaj ka “chakravyuh” koi instant loan app ho sakta hai, betting ya gaming app, ya koi aisa group jahan ghusna ek click hai. Ghusne se pehle khud se poochhiye: “Bahar kaise nikloonga?”

2. Plan doosron ke vaade par tika tha. Abhimanyu ka pravesh is shart par tha ki baaki sab peechhe aayenge. Vaada saccha tha, par poora nahi ho paaya. Team project ho ya startup, sirf “sab saath denge” par poora plan mat tikaiye. Ek Plan B rakhiye.

3. Adhoora gyaan bhi gyaan hai, bas uski seema pata ho. Abhimanyu ne apni seema chhupayi nahi. Interview ho ya naukri, “mujhe yeh aata hai, yeh nahi aata” saaf bolna himmat ki baat hai.

Bachche ke liye: Koi online game ya app jisme “bas ek aur level” chalta rahe, use kholne se pehle sochiye ki band kab karenge.

Student ke liye: Group study mein agar sab “main kar lunga” bolte hain, to apna hissa likh lijiye aur deadline tay kar lijiye.

Kaam karne walon ke liye: Naya role ya naya loan lene se pehle exit ka rasta samjhiye: notice period, prepayment charge, lock-in.

Mahabharat se aur: Yaksh-Yudhishthira samvaad: sansaar ki sabse ajeeb baat aur Bhishma ki pratijna aur dharm ka arth.

Ek sawaal ghar pe

Aapki zindagi mein aisa kaunsa “vyuh” hai jismein aap ghus to gaye, par nikalne ka rasta abhi pata nahi? Agar hai, to sharm ki baat nahi. Abhimanyu ne bhi apni seema saaf boli thi.

Log ye bhi poochhte hain

Abhimanyu ko chakravyuh kisne sikhaaya tha?

Granth ke is prasang mein Abhimanyu khud kehta hai ki use pita (Arjuna) ne sena ka vyuh todne ka upaay sikhaaya hai. Garbh mein seekhne ki baat Ganguli ke anuvaad ke is section mein nahi hai.

Abhimanyu chakravyuh se bahar kyun nahi nikal paaya?

Usne pehle hi kaha tha ki aapatti aane par woh bahar nahi nikal paayega. Yudhishthira aur Bhima ne peechhe aane ka vaada kiya, par Pandav andar nahi pahunch paaye, aur andar kai Kaurav maharathi ek saath usse lade.

Chakravyuh kisne banaya tha?

Yudh ke terahvein din Drona ne yeh vyuh banaya, jise Ganguli ke anuvaad mein “chakra” array kaha gaya hai. Us samay Arjuna doosri taraf yudh mein vyast the.

Garbh mein chakravyuh seekhne wali kahani kahan se aayi?

Wikipedia ka Abhimanyu article ise “later folklore” (baad ki lok-katha) batata hai. Yeh kahani kis granth ya kis sadi se shuru hui, iski pakki tika humein abhi nahi mili.

Galti dikhe to bohotsimplehai@gmail.com par likhein; sudhaar date ke saath dikhaya jaayega.

Newsletter · Ravivaar Ka Saar

Hafte ki sabse kaam ki cheezein, ek email mein

Pehla edition jaldi. Har Ravivaar ek email — koi spam nahi, ek click mein unsubscribe.

Hum sirf aapka email, aapki haan ka samay aur kis page se jude, ye rakhte hain. Kisi ko becha ya diya nahi jaata. Privacy

Apni raay likhein